Archives > News

Print | E-mail | Rate | Text Size

Landlords miffed by high water, sewer rate

Monthly fee targets empty rentals.

By JEFF M. HARDISON
jhardison@lakecityreporter.com
Published: Tuesday, November 18, 2008 6:14 AM EST
A $47 monthly fee for the availability of water and sewer service is too high, according to Karen Mizer, president of the Columbia County Landlords Association.

Mizer was speaking on behalf of the many people who own and rent property in Lake City and the surrounding utility service area. The City Council Chambers were half-full of such people Monday night as the owners showed up to address this grievance.

In March 2007, this ordinance passed to assess the fee, Mizer said.

“No landlords, Realtors or developers were aware of this ordinance until we started receiving bills,” Mizer said.


In September 2007, the association was told there would have to be another rate study to revise this practice.

In the spring of 2008, the association sought an update and she was told a new rate study is needed, she said.

“Now, one-and-a-half years after this ordinance passes, we have no answers,” Mizer said.

Affordable housing is a necessity for any community to survive, she said. This availability cost has to be passed on to renters or small property owners are going out of business.

“We are not unreasonable,” she said. “If this was a $10 fee, or maybe a $15 (monthly) fee, that would be reasonable. Forty-seven dollars a month for absolutely nothing is hard to swallow.”

Mizer has 81 vacant units and has to pay $3,800 for availability this month alone. There is no income from vacant units.

“If you want to keep people here in Lake City with a place to live — because we know the housing market is suffering — we need some relief from this issue,” Mizer said.

City Manager Scott Reynolds said he anticipates sending out requests for proposals for a new rate study within the week.

City Councilman George Ward said the availability fee is a requirement, because the city promises certain gallons of water and sewer service as being available.

That commitment has been promised and allocated, Ward said.

Tom Eagle, another residential landlord, said he has 130 units in the city and 25 of them are vacant. At almost $50 a month, that’s around $1,200 a month that he is paying.

In other property he has available, there are 10 houses in the $150,000 to $160,000 range for sale in the Cypress Landing subdivision, Eagle said.

The city is killing new development, he said: It costs him $10,000 before he turns the first shovelful of dirt because of impact fees and water and sewer tap fees.

“We try, and we try and we try to have affordable housing available here,” he said.

The city is making that difficult, he added. In the past three years, he has not raised his rent one nickel. And this, he said, is despite increased fire fees.

Mayor Stephen Witt thanked the people for sharing their thoughts with City Council.



Previous   Next
Carrier to dock in Jax   City eyes fouled land

Article Rating

Current Rating: 0 of 0 votes!Rate File:
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the view of lakecityreporter.com.

Get Over It wrote on Nov 18, 2008 9:34 AM:

" Everyone is paying the fee, a lot of folks with a lot less resources than Karen Mizer and the Columbia County Landlords Association and her members. Step up to the plate Columbia County Landlords Association and pay your fair share! A failing business plan does not mean that you should be exempted from fees that individuals have to pay! "

one of the impacted wrote on Nov 18, 2008 10:28 AM:

" Seems to me the city would realize this and adjust this rate appropriately so that parents are better able to feed thier children and pay thier utilities, not having to choose between the two, and less dependant on state support. And I hear people say, then you shoudn't have had children if you can't afford them. But, when I had my children, planned my family, gas was a dollar per gallon and utilities were only half what they are now, only a few years later. Who would have forseen prices skyrocketing?

I believe the city should absolutely change these rates. Where is all of that money going anyways? Ask a city employee what they earn per hour---it's measly! So where's all that money going? "

Lake City born and bred wrote on Nov 18, 2008 12:23 PM:

" I am Lake City born and bred and feel the need to comment on this subject...Affordable rent, Mr. Eagle? To who? The people who can't buy a house must therefore rent and the price for rentals in Lake City is ridiculous...I love Lake City, but there is nothing in this town that justifies current rent amounts. What kind of job is there is Lake City that will afford someone that isn't paying a mortgage to even have a roof over their head? I ask, what happened in Lake City that middle to lower income people are having to live with friends or family just to make ends meet? "

Senior Chief wrote on Nov 18, 2008 3:04 PM:

" To Lake City born and bred. What happened to affordable housing? Here is a laundry list of things that effect housing cost as well as all other living expenses (not all inclusive):

Mandatory Minimum Wage
Insurance (both property and liability)
Building Codes causing escalating construction cost
Availability Fees for city services
Taxes Taxes and more Taxes

If you want prices to start stabilizing (they will never go down) then you need to vote for people who will try to control the cost of government rather than continue to raise taxes and fees to pay for un-necessary expensive programs. "

Renter wrote on Nov 18, 2008 3:33 PM:

" I have to agree with "lake city born and bred"! I am also a renter in Lake City and recently found myself having to look for another place to live. The cost for rental Apartments and homes in Lake City is absolutely INSANE!!! a 700 sq ft 2 bed/1ba home is running around 750.00. that is just way toooo much for this area! "

My 2 cents wrote on Nov 18, 2008 7:38 PM:

" I'll add on here. Some of the ones who are complaining about the fee have owned their properties for some time. They aren't "victims" of buying rental property at inflated values, they have had them for years. What does this mean? Assuming they still have mortgages on the properties, the amount the renters are paying is much, much more than enough to cover the mortgage payments and then some. These same developers who cry about how expensive it is to build would also be the same ones who would start crying that there wasn't water available on a future project. As a developer in areas outside of LC, I have learned that its worth it to pay a minimal charge and keep the availability than to beg for availability down the road. The fees in LC are comparable to other places I have been, lower in many. I know times are tough, but the developers and rental unit owners chose to play the game...so play it. "

Return to: News « | Home « | Top of Page ^
Today's Weather
Lake City, FL
Sponsored by: